At Tasty Pizza, the secret’s not in the sauce or even the crust – it’s the family.

Opened 59 years ago by family partriarch Joe Compola and his wife Mary, Tasty Pizza has been a part of life in Lyndhurst for countless customers who grew up eating pizza there and who now bring their families to dine.

Carrying on the Compola family tradition, daughter Jackie and husband Joe Woytovich have kept things the same, including the homelike atmosphere.

“It’s always been homestyle, help yourself type of dining. We want our customers to feel at ease here and they seem to like it.”
- Jackie Woytovich
The family of Tasty Pizza hope that you too will become part of this tradition. So please check out our website and come by soon for the Tasty experience.
Join our mailing list, to receive a chance to win our
monthly drawing for a $20 gift certificate
We value your privacy and will never spam you